Did you know? · Philosophy & Thought

Bergson's last book called for an open, universal morality

In The Two Sources of Morality and Religion (1932), Henri Bergson contrasted a closed morality of the group with an open morality of love for all.

Henri Bergson
Henri Bergson · 1859–1941
Person
Henri Bergson
Lived
1859–1941
Field
Philosophy
From
French

The story

In the 1920s Henri Bergson suffered from severe arthritis that eventually forced him to withdraw from public life. The Collège de France relieved him of his teaching duties so that he could work on a new book on ethics, religion and society, and his disciple Édouard Le Roy took over his lectures. In 1932, to general surprise, he published his last major work, Les deux sources de la morale et de la religion (The Two Sources of Morality and Religion).

Bergson said the book developed ideas from Creative Evolution. He argued that morality has two sources. Closed morality and static religion serve social cohesion: they bind members of a group together, as nature binds the members of a beehive, and enforce strict obedience. Because closed morality concerns the survival of one particular society, it always excludes others and is bound up with war. Static religion supports it through what Bergson called the fabulation function, the imagination's power to invent images of gods that watch over the group.

Open morality and dynamic religion, by contrast, are concerned with creativity and progress, and open the way beyond the closed group. Because it includes everyone, open morality is genuinely universal and aims at peace and an open society. Its source is creative emotion, of the kind that drives a composer to write a symphony, and Bergson found it above all in the great mystics, whose experience led to action and not just contemplation. In the book, the Stanford Encyclopedia notes, sympathy progresses to the point of love for all things.

The book prompted renewed debate about his philosophy and his religious views. It was respectfully received by the public and by philosophers, and his former student Jacques Maritain, who had become a critic, came to praise Bergson after it appeared.

Published as nationalism and dictatorship were rising across Europe, The Two Sources offered a powerful argument that true morality cannot stop at the borders of one's own group. Its contrast between closed and open societies has continued to influence thinkers on ethics, religion and politics.

Why it matters

Bergson's vision of an open morality, reaching beyond any single group to all of humanity, inspired later thinkers on ethics and society.

About Henri Bergson

French philosopher of time, memory and the élan vital who won the 1927 Nobel Prize in Literature and, drawn to Catholicism, chose to remain among the persecuted Jews.

Read the full profile
Henri Bergson
1859–1941 · Philosophy
View profile →

More about Henri Bergson

Sources

Another act of tikkun olam. This is part of tikkun olam, the Jewish idea of repairing the world, and every one of us can add to it.

More in Philosophy & Thought

On kindness & the treatment of others
“A friend is devoted at all times; a brother is born to share adversity.”
Proverbs 17:17