Did you know? · Jewish Heritage

Schoenberg's Moses und Aron wrestled with an unseen God

Arnold Schoenberg's opera Moses und Aron, composed 1930–32, dramatises the Jewish idea of a God who cannot be pictured, through the clash of two brothers.

Arnold Schoenberg
Arnold Schoenberg · 1874–1951
Person
Arnold Schoenberg
Lived
1874–1951
Field
Composition
From
Austrian-American

The story

The roots of Moses und Aron lie in a humiliation. In the summer of 1921 Arnold Schoenberg was forced to leave the Austrian resort of Mattsee because he was a Jew, even though he had converted to Protestantism years before. Two years later he wrote to the painter Wassily Kandinsky that he had learned the lesson forced upon him: that he was not a German or a European, but a Jew. He responded first with a play, Der biblische Weg (The Biblical Way), whose hero was partly modelled on Theodor Herzl, and then with an oratorio that became an opera.

Schoenberg wrote both the German libretto and the music, based on episodes from the Book of Exodus, and composed the first two acts between 1930 and 1932. Moses grasps the idea of one invisible, unimaginable God but cannot find words to share it, while his eloquent brother Aron can reach the people only through images, culminating in the golden calf. To embody the contrast, Moses is a speaking role and Aron a lyrical tenor.

The whole opera is built from a single twelve-tone row. It turns a central Jewish idea, the prohibition on making images of God, into a drama about the limits of art and language. The Milken Archive says it occupies a central position in Schoenberg's work, and it is widely regarded as his masterpiece.

He planned a third act and wrote its libretto, but never set it to music, and the opera usually ends with Moses lamenting that he lacks the word. Schoenberg always meant to finish it, so it was not staged in his lifetime. The Dance around the Golden Calf was performed at Darmstadt on 2 July 1951, eleven days before he died; a concert performance followed in Hamburg in 1954, and the first staging took place in Zurich on 6 June 1957.

Since then the opera has reached the world's great houses: Covent Garden under Georg Solti in 1965, Boston in 1966 and the Metropolitan Opera in 1999. It was filmed by Jean-Marie Straub and Danièle Huillet in 1973, and it remains one of the most debated operas of the century.

Why it matters

Moses und Aron brought deep questions of Jewish thought onto the world's opera stages, where it is still performed and debated.

About Arnold Schoenberg

Viennese composer who broke with traditional harmony, invented the twelve-tone method, and returned to Judaism in defiance of the Nazis, writing Moses und Aron and A Survivor from Warsaw.

Read the full profile
Arnold Schoenberg
1874–1951 · Composition
View profile →

More about Arnold Schoenberg

Sources

Another act of tikkun olam. This is part of tikkun olam, the Jewish idea of repairing the world, and every one of us can add to it.

More in Jewish Heritage

On kindness & the treatment of others
“A friend is devoted at all times; a brother is born to share adversity.”
Proverbs 17:17