Did you know? · Humanitarian Work

Louis Brandeis held 57 hearings to reform Boston poorhouses

In 1894 Louis Brandeis spent nine months and held 57 public hearings on Boston's poorhouses, leading the city to completely reorganise how it cared for the poor.

Louis Brandeis
Louis Brandeis · 1856–1941
Person
Louis Brandeis
Lived
1856–1941
Field
Law
From
American

The story

By the early 1890s Louis Brandeis was a successful Boston lawyer. Born in Louisville, Kentucky, to Jewish immigrants from Prague, he had graduated top of his class at Harvard Law School in 1877 and built a thriving practice with his classmate Samuel Warren. With his finances secure, he began to take on public causes. In 1891 he won his first important public victory, persuading the Massachusetts legislature to make the state's liquor laws more reasonable and enforceable.

One of his first public interest cases came in 1894, when he represented Alice N. Lincoln, a Boston philanthropist and well-known crusader for the poor. Lincoln had visited the city's public poorhouses for years and had seen inmates living in misery, with people who were only temporarily out of work housed together with the mentally ill and hardened criminals.

Brandeis took up the cause at public hearings, pressing for an investigation into conditions. He spent nine months on the case and held fifty-seven public hearings. At one he declared that men are not bad but are degraded largely by circumstances, and that it is the duty of everyone to help them up and give them hope. The evidence was persuasive: as a result of the hearings, Boston's board of aldermen ordered that the administration of the poor law be completely reorganised.

The case set the pattern for the rest of Brandeis's career, in which he used his legal skill on behalf of people who had no one else to speak for them. Two years later he led a successful fight against a transit company seeking control of Boston's new subway system, and in the following decades he took on the insurance industry and J. P. Morgan's railroad empire, usually refusing payment so that he could pursue the public interest freely. He became known as 'the People's Lawyer'.

In his 1911 book The Opportunity in the Law, he explained that the public was often poorly represented or not represented at all when laws were made, and urged young lawyers to fill that gap. His approach of gathering facts in public to win humane reform influenced generations of public interest lawyers.

Why it matters

The hearings forced Boston to overhaul the way it treated its poorest residents, and showed how a lawyer could use public evidence to win humane reform.

About Louis Brandeis

“The People’s Lawyer” who became the first Jewish Supreme Court justice in 1916, wrote classic defences of free speech and privacy, and led American Zionism.

Read the full profile
Louis Brandeis
1856–1941 · Law
View profile →

More about Louis Brandeis

Sources

Another act of tikkun olam. This is part of tikkun olam, the Jewish idea of repairing the world, and every one of us can add to it.

More in Humanitarian Work

On kindness & the treatment of others
“A friend is devoted at all times; a brother is born to share adversity.”
Proverbs 17:17