Did you know? · Science & Medicine

Otto Stern found the proton is not a simple particle

In 1933 Otto Stern, Otto Frisch and Immanuel Estermann measured the proton's magnetism and found it unexpectedly large, the first sign that the proton has inner structure.

Otto Stern
Otto Stern · 1888–1969
Person
Otto Stern
Lived
1888–1969
Field
Experimental physics
From
German-American

The story

Theory in the early 1930s, based on Paul Dirac's equation for particles with spin, treated the proton as a simple point-like particle and predicted exactly how magnetic it should be: one nuclear magneton, the proton's equivalent of the electron's basic unit of magnetism. Measuring something so small, about two thousand times weaker than an electron's magnetism, was one of the most ambitious goals Otto Stern had set for his Hamburg laboratory in 1926.

In the spring of 1933, Stern and Otto Robert Frisch finally succeeded in deflecting a beam of hydrogen molecules with a magnetic field, a very demanding experiment even today. It was complicated by the fact that only one form of hydrogen, ortho-hydrogen, carries a nuclear magnetic moment, and by the small magnetism caused by the molecules' rotation. Stern recalled that theoreticians chided them for measuring something they thought they already knew.

The proton turned out to be far more magnetic than expected. Frisch and Stern's first estimate was 2 to 3 nuclear magnetons. Less than two months later Stern and Immanuel Estermann repeated the measurement and reported 2.5, with an error of about 10 per cent, consistent with today's accepted value of about 2.79. The result showed that the proton is not an elementary particle. Rabi's group at Columbia confirmed the unexpectedly large value, and in 1939 measured it precisely.

The measurement was made as the Nazis were forcing Jewish scientists out of German universities. Estermann and Frisch received their letters of dismissal on 23 June 1933, and Stern resigned a week later, so it was among the last results of his Hamburg laboratory. It earned a central place in his 1943 Nobel Prize citation, which honoured his discovery of the magnetic moment of the proton.

The puzzle of the proton's magnetism remained unsolved for some 30 years, until the quark model of the 1960s showed that protons are built from three smaller particles whose magnetic moments combine. Today the proton's magnetism is exploited in proton nuclear magnetic resonance, which chemists use to study molecules and which underlies the MRI scans used in hospitals.

Why it matters

The discovery opened the path toward understanding that protons are made of quarks, and the proton's magnetism is the basis of the MRI scans used in hospitals worldwide.

About Otto Stern

Physicist whose molecular-beam method proved space quantisation in the Stern–Gerlach experiment and measured the proton’s magnetic moment; Nobel Prize in Physics 1943.

Read the full profile
Otto Stern
1888–1969 · Experimental physics
View profile →

More about Otto Stern

Sources

Another act of tikkun olam. This is part of tikkun olam, the Jewish idea of repairing the world, and every one of us can add to it.

More in Science & Medicine

On kindness & the treatment of others
“A friend is devoted at all times; a brother is born to share adversity.”
Proverbs 17:17