Did you know? · Business & Tech

Simon Kuznets warned that GDP does not measure welfare

Simon Kuznets helped standardise the measurement of national output, but cautioned that a nation's welfare can scarcely be inferred from a measure of national income.

Simon Kuznets
Simon Kuznets · 1901–1985
Person
Simon Kuznets
Lived
1901–1985
Field
Economics
From
Russian-born American

The story

Simon Kuznets did more than anyone to build the modern measure of a nation's output. Beginning in 1931 at the National Bureau of Economic Research, he produced the first official estimates of US national income, later extending them back to 1869. He pioneered the concept now known as gross domestic product, which tries to capture all economic production in a country in a single number, and he helped the US Department of Commerce standardise the measurement of gross national product.

Yet Kuznets was clear about the limits of his own creation. He disapproved of using national income as a general indicator of well-being, writing that the welfare of a nation can scarcely be inferred from a measure of national income. A single total, however carefully calculated, said nothing about who received the income, how people lived or what the society valued.

His own research reflected that view. He studied how income was distributed among households and how the structure of society changed as economies grew, not just the overall total. He analysed proportions between output and income, consumption and savings, and used long series of data to test theories, showing in 1942 that a prediction drawn from Keynes about rising savings did not hold over the long run. His comparison of inequality across countries led to the idea known as the Kuznets curve.

Kuznets also looked beyond economics narrowly defined. He tied growth to demography, the spread of knowledge and institutions, and in his studies of the 1970s he stressed how science and technology interacted with institutional change and how the moral and political climate of a society could affect the course of growth. He was influenced by thinkers such as A. C. Pigou, who studied when markets fail to maximise welfare.

His warning has outlived him. Debates about measuring well-being alongside output, and efforts to track inequality, health and quality of life next to GDP, echo the caution of the man who created the numbers. For Kuznets, national income figures were a starting point for understanding a society, never the final word on its welfare.

Why it matters

Kuznets's warning reminds policymakers that economic output is a tool for understanding prosperity, not a full measure of human welfare.

About Simon Kuznets

Pinsk-born economist who built the first official estimates of US national income, laying the foundations of GDP, and won the 1971 Nobel Prize for his empirical study of economic growth.

Read the full profile
Simon Kuznets
1901–1985 · Economics
View profile →

More about Simon Kuznets

Sources

Another act of tikkun olam. This is part of tikkun olam, the Jewish idea of repairing the world, and every one of us can add to it.

More in Business & Tech

On kindness & the treatment of others
“A friend is devoted at all times; a brother is born to share adversity.”
Proverbs 17:17