Did you know? · Philosophy & Thought

Wigner asked why mathematics describes nature so well

Eugene Wigner's 1960 essay The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Mathematics in the Natural Sciences asked why abstract mathematics fits the physical world so astonishingly well.

Eugene Wigner
Eugene Wigner · 1902–1995
Person
Eugene Wigner
Lived
1902–1995
Field
Theoretical physics
From
Hungarian-American

The story

Eugene Wigner spent his career watching mathematics invented for its own sake turn out to describe nature with uncanny precision. Group theory, developed by pure mathematicians, had become in his hands the language of atomic spectra and nuclear physics. In later life his thoughts turned increasingly to philosophical questions about science.

In 1959 he gave the Richard Courant Lecture in Mathematical Sciences at New York University under the title "The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Mathematics in the Natural Sciences". It was published in 1960 in the journal Communications on Pure and Applied Mathematics. Wigner observed that mathematical concepts developed independently of physics, often so that mathematicians could display their ingenuity and sense of formal beauty, nevertheless keep finding precise applications in physics.

He gave striking examples. Newton's law of gravitation, based on very limited observations of falling bodies and the moon, proved accurate for the planets far beyond reasonable expectation. Matrix mechanics, built on rules mathematicians had worked out long before, gave a calculation of the lowest energy level of helium that matched experiment to about one part in ten million. The quantum theory of the Lamb shift agreed with measurement to better than one part in a thousand. Albert Einstein and Alfred North Whitehead had seen the success of mathematics as a mystery, but Wigner's lecture became the classic statement of the problem. He suggested that biology and human cognition may shape physical concepts as we perceive them, but found the happy match between mathematics and physics hard to explain.

The essay became his best-known work outside technical mathematics and physics, and it has provoked responses across many disciplines. In 1980 the computer scientist Richard Hamming examined four partial explanations and found none satisfying. Others have extended the question to molecular biology, data mining, economics and the philosophy of mathematics, and the physicist Max Tegmark has engaged with it in physics.

More than sixty years later, scientists and philosophers still cite Wigner's essay whenever they ask why the abstract patterns of mathematics fit the physical world so well. Its title has become a familiar phrase, borrowed by writers in fields from computer science to economics to frame the same question about their own disciplines.

Why it matters

Wigner's essay remains one of the most widely discussed reflections on why science works, inspiring debate across many disciplines.

About Eugene Wigner

Budapest-born Nobel physicist who brought symmetry and group theory into quantum mechanics, helped launch the Manhattan Project and designed the first plutonium production reactors.

Read the full profile
Eugene Wigner
1902–1995 · Theoretical physics
View profile →

More about Eugene Wigner

Sources

Another act of tikkun olam. This is part of tikkun olam, the Jewish idea of repairing the world, and every one of us can add to it.

More in Philosophy & Thought

On kindness & the treatment of others
“A friend is devoted at all times; a brother is born to share adversity.”
Proverbs 17:17