Did you know? · Law & Justice

Joel Spingarn lost his job defending a colleague

In 1910 Joel Spingarn offered a faculty resolution supporting a Columbia professor summarily dismissed by the university's president, and was himself dismissed weeks later.

Joel Spingarn
Joel Spingarn · 1875–1939
Person
Joel Spingarn
Lived
1875–1939
Field
Civil rights & criticism
From
American

The story

Joel Spingarn had studied and taught at Columbia University for most of his adult life. After graduating in 1895 and earning his doctorate in 1899, he joined the new Department of Comparative Literature under his mentor George E. Woodberry, rising to full professor in 1909 and department head in 1910. From 1904 his role in university affairs marked him as an independent spirit at Columbia, too independent for its powerful president, Nicholas Murray Butler. Their differences ranged from clashes of personality to disagreements over educational philosophy.

Matters came to a head in 1910 when Butler summarily dismissed Professor Harry Thurston Peck over a public scandal involving a breach-of-promise lawsuit. At a faculty meeting Spingarn offered a resolution in Peck's support. Five weeks later Spingarn himself was dismissed. EBSCO's biography describes the clash as a dispute over free speech at the university.

Spingarn joined a distinguished line of progressive scholars, including Woodberry, Charles Beard and James Harvey Robinson, who resigned or were dismissed during Butler's presidency. Independently wealthy, he continued his scholarship, occasionally teaching at the New School for Social Research. He never returned to a permanent academic post, but he went on publishing criticism, including The New Criticism in 1911 and Creative Criticism in 1917.

His dismissal coincided with the formation of the NAACP, and he poured much of his energy into the fight for racial justice. Early in 1911 he was already acting for its New York Vigilance Committee, and he went on to chair its board, serve as treasurer and become its president. In 1911 he also bought the Amenia Times, a local newspaper near his country estate in New York's Dutchess County, and later he helped found the publisher Harcourt, Brace.

Losing his professorship freed Spingarn to become a public figure rather than a campus one. The independence that had troubled Columbia's president became an asset in the civil rights movement, where he was willing to take unpopular positions and stand by them.

Why it matters

Spingarn's willingness to sacrifice his post for a principle foreshadowed the courage he would bring to the civil rights movement.

About Joel Spingarn

Literary scholar who became one of the NAACP’s first Jewish leaders, its chairman, treasurer and second president, and founder of the Spingarn Medal for African American achievement.

Read the full profile
Joel Spingarn
1875–1939 · Civil rights & criticism
View profile →

More about Joel Spingarn

Sources

Another act of tikkun olam. This is part of tikkun olam, the Jewish idea of repairing the world, and every one of us can add to it.

More in Law & Justice

On kindness & the treatment of others
“A friend is devoted at all times; a brother is born to share adversity.”
Proverbs 17:17