Did you know? · Science & Medicine

I. I. Rabi opposed the hydrogen bomb on moral grounds

In 1949 Isidor Isaac Rabi joined Enrico Fermi on the AEC's advisory committee in opposing the hydrogen bomb on moral as well as technical grounds.

Isidor Isaac Rabi
Isidor Isaac Rabi · 1898–1988
Person
Isidor Isaac Rabi
Lived
1898–1988
Field
Physics
From
Polish-born American

The story

Isidor Isaac Rabi knew the power of nuclear weapons at first hand. He had served as a consultant to the Manhattan Project, and in July 1945 he watched the Trinity test, the first atomic explosion, through welding goggles. In December 1946 he was appointed to the General Advisory Committee of the new Atomic Energy Commission, a nine-member panel created to advise on scientific and technical matters.

In August 1949 the Soviet Union tested its first atomic bomb, and the White House announced it that September. Some American officials and scientists pressed for a crash programme to build a far more powerful weapon, the hydrogen or "super" bomb. The question went to the committee, which met in Washington on 29 and 30 October 1949 under the chairmanship of J. Robert Oppenheimer.

No member of the committee was willing to endorse an all-out effort. The majority report warned that the weapon's use would involve a decision to slaughter vast numbers of civilians. Rabi went further than most of his colleagues. Together with Enrico Fermi he wrote a separate annex arguing that the bomb should be opposed on moral as well as technical grounds. The two physicists wrote that because there was no limit to the destructiveness of such a weapon, its very existence was a danger to humanity as a whole, and they called it necessarily an evil thing. They urged the President to declare that developing it was wrong on fundamental ethical principles and to invite other nations to join a solemn pledge not to build such weapons.

President Harry S. Truman overruled the committee in January 1950 and ordered development to proceed. Rabi later said he never forgave Truman for giving in to the pressure. He kept speaking out. He succeeded Oppenheimer as chairman of the committee from 1952 to 1956, and at the 1954 security hearing that stripped Oppenheimer of his clearance, no witness defended his friend more forcefully. The Atomic Heritage Foundation notes that Rabi also worked with Oppenheimer to support the Baruch Plan for international control of atomic energy.

The Fermi-Rabi annex remains one of the clearest statements by scientists of their responsibility to weigh the moral consequences of the weapons they help to create.

Why it matters

Rabi's stand helped establish the principle that scientists have a responsibility to weigh the moral consequences of the weapons they create.

About Isidor Isaac Rabi

Galician-born physicist who discovered nuclear magnetic resonance in molecular beams, won the 1944 Nobel Prize, and helped found Brookhaven and CERN, the root of today’s MRI and atomic clocks.

Read the full profile
Isidor Isaac Rabi
1898–1988 · Physics
View profile →

More about Isidor Isaac Rabi

Sources

Another act of tikkun olam. This is part of tikkun olam, the Jewish idea of repairing the world, and every one of us can add to it.

More in Science & Medicine

On kindness & the treatment of others
“A friend is devoted at all times; a brother is born to share adversity.”
Proverbs 17:17